Adaptively Refined Large-Eddy Simulations of Galaxy Clusters

Appendix H Fluid dynamics in comoving coordinates

H.1 Introduction

On large scales (> 100Mpc) the distribution of matter in the universe is isotropic (it looks the same in all directions) and homogeneous (it is isotropic at each point). But only the space is assumed to be isotropic and homogenous. The observed expansion of the universe singles out a special direction in time.6262In other words: The universe is not a maximally symmetric 4-dimensional manifold, but can be depicted as maximally symmetric 3-dimensional spacelike sheets in a 4-dimensional spacetime. The metric on such a manifold is the Robertson-Walker-metric.

The physical distance on large scales6363This is a very important point. If the space would also expand on small scales we couldn’t measure the expansion, because everything including our distance measurement device would expand. But on small scales the universe is not homogenous. On small scales the metric of the universe is not a Robertson-Walker metric, but more like a Schwarzschild metric, which is isotropic, but not homogenous. between two points in such an expanding universe varies with time like

ri=a(t)xi. (H.1)

The factor a is a dimensionless scale factor greater than zero, which must be the same for each component of the distance vector because of the assumed isotropy. The scale factor can only depend on the time t and not on the position xi because of the assumed homogeneity of space.

The change of the distance with time in an expanding universe is then

r˙i=a˙xi+ax˙i. (H.2)

The global velocity of a particle vi=r˙i which does not move relative to the expanding space (x˙i=0) is

v˙i=a˙xi=a˙ari=H(t)ri (H.3)

where H is the so called Hubble parameter. Is a particle moving relative to the expanding space (x˙i0) then we measure the additional local (also called proper) velocity ui=ax˙i of the particle. This local velocity can, according to special relativity, be never greater than the speed of light c. Nevertheless, the global velocity (e.g. the measured escape velocities of galaxies at great distances) can be greater than c (Davis and Lineweaver, 2004). Generally the physical velocity of a particle is the sum of global and local velocity

vi=a˙xi+ui(xi,t). (H.4)

H.2 Useful transformations

From the definition of the distance ri and the velocity vi in comoving coordinates we get

ri =1axi, (H.5)
rivi =1axiui+3a˙a, (H.6)
rivj =1axiuj+a˙aδij, (H.7)
(At)r+vjArj =(At)x+1aujAxj, (H.8)
A(ri,vi,t) A(xi,ui,t). (H.9)

With the help of transformation (H.6) and (H.7) we can transform the stress tensor for a newtonian fluid in cartesian coordinates

σij=2η[12(rjvi+rivj)-1nδijrkvk]+ζδijrkvk (H.10)

into the stress tensor for a newtonian fluid in comoving coordinates

σij= 2η[12(1axjui+a˙aδij+1axiuj+a˙aδji)-1nδij(1axkuk+na˙a)] (H.11)
+ζδij(1axkuk+na˙a) (H.12)
= 2η[12a(xjui+xiuj)+a˙aδij-nna˙aδij-1naδijxkuk] (H.13)
+ζδij(1axkuk+na˙a) (H.14)
= 1a{2η[12(xjui+xiuj)-1nδijxkuk]+ζδij(xkuk+na˙)}. (H.15)

H.3 Equations in comoving coordinates

With the help of the relations described in the last section, we can write down the fluid dynamic equations in explicit comoving form

tρ+1axj(ujρ)= -3a˙aρ, (H.16)
t(ρui)+1axj(ujρui)= -1axip+1axjσij+ρgi*-4a˙aρui, (H.17)
t(ρe)+1axj(ujρe)=-1axj(ujp)+1axj(uiσij)+1auiρgi*-3a˙a(ρe+13ρui2+p), (H.18)

with Newtonian Gravity in comoving coordinates (Poisson Equation)

1axigi*=4πG, (H.19)

where gi*=-1aφxi and the gauge transformed newtonian potential φ=ϕ+12aa¨xi2.

The energy equation is the sum of the equation for the kinetic energy and the internal energy

t(ρek)+1axj(ujρek) =-1auixip+1auixjσij+1aρuigi*-5a˙aρek, (H.20)
t(ρeint)+1axj(ujρeint) =-1apxjuj-1aσijxjui-3a˙a(ρeint+p). (H.21)

A even simpler form of the equations of fluid dynamics in comoving coordinates can be found by expressing density and pressure in comoving coordinates. The connection between the density in physical coordinates ri=a(t)xi and the comoving coordinates xi is given by

ρ(ri)=dMdV=dMdr1dr2dr3=1a(t)3dMdx1dx2dx3=1a(t)3ρ(xi)=1a(t)3ρ~ (H.22)

and in analogy for the pressure

p(ri)=1a(t)3p(xi)=1a(t)3p~. (H.23)

Because

tρ=t1a(t)3ρ~=1a(t)3tρ~-3a˙aρ (H.24)

the source term on the right hand side of the momentum equation (H.17) and energy conservation equation (H.18) is reduced and even vanishes in the mass conservation equation (H.16), so that we can write the system of equations for fluid dynamic in comoving coordinates like

tρ~+1axj(ujρ~)= 0, (H.25)
t(ρ~ui)+1axj(ujρ~ui)= -1axip~+1axjσij+ρ~gi*-a˙aρ~ui, (H.26)
t(ρ~e)+1axj(ujρ~e)=-1axj(ujp~)+1axj(uiσij)+1auiρ~gi*-a˙a(ρ~e+13ρ~ui2+p~). (H.27)